James Kierstead
@kleisthenes2
Senior Fellow @nzinitiative, co-host @FreeKiwis, advisor @nzfreespeech, on ed board @InquiryOpen, @AntigoneJournal, ex/X classicist 🇨🇦🇬🇧
ID: 838302908886073344
https://owlofathena.substack.com/ 05-03-2017 08:19:23
18,18K Tweet
3,3K Followers
6,6K Following
Michelle Psycho Milt 🗣 Free Speech Union ✊ NZ Law Commission Paul Goldsmith 2) none of this means we should be considering making some people’s beliefs (or persistently stated beliefs) about these issues illegal
Michelle Psycho Milt 🗣 Free Speech Union ✊ NZ Law Commission Paul Goldsmith Another think I like about the analogy is that there are certain communities in which belief in these phenomena are expected, and in some cases even used as a condition for remaining in the community
Michelle Psycho Milt 🗣 Free Speech Union ✊ NZ Law Commission Paul Goldsmith Why should employees have to put up with others curtailing their beliefs about perfectly ordinary things, like others’ sex? Having the law compel people to voice a certain view would obviously be a major affront to liberal values
Michelle Psycho Milt 🗣 Free Speech Union ✊ NZ Law Commission Paul Goldsmith What if I sail to a Catholic colleague that I thought belief in transsubstantiation was silly? Would that reduce his dignity and respect? Should I be forced to say I do believe in transsubstantiation?
James Kierstead Psycho Milt 🗣 Free Speech Union ✊ NZ Law Commission Paul Goldsmith Mostly at work I just talk about work things and try to be pleasant and respectful to colleagues. Religion does not often come up.
James Kierstead I liked The Turn of the Screw.
This is fascinating and suggests just how endemic the New Zealand academic free speech issues raised by James Kierstead have become. thespinoff.co.nz/books/03-10-20…
Michelle Psycho Milt 🗣 Free Speech Union ✊ NZ Law Commission Paul Goldsmith I think this is a difference with the trans debate. If someone identifies as a different sex (or gender), then you probably will be in the position to have to refer to them with pronouns at some point.
Michelle Psycho Milt 🗣 Free Speech Union ✊ NZ Law Commission Paul Goldsmith But the fact that the choice of what to say in this case comes up more regularly doesn't affect the principle. People should not be constrained by the law to say things that they don't believe
To be fair, James Kierstead, you tried this with *What Maisie Knew* and it nearly ended you
🧵Prof. Michael Rainsborough (Michael Rainsborough) was head of War Studies at KCL. In 2019, he co-wrote a paper in support of Brexit. He was summoned to a meeting with his faculty dean. "People are unhappy with you" he was told. "We'll be looking towards you stepping down."