Falcon Punch
@tqcpfp
Oh Frankie, we are all Architects!
ID: 69314463
https://cutt.ly/swgMkXIX 27-08-2009 15:08:16
21,21K Tweet
1,1K Followers
908 Following
A prominent discussion was gabrielwinant's in Dissent Magazine. This essay played a meaningful role shaping a lot of left wing conversation around 10/7. Gabe did not defend Hamas's assault here. He rightly focused proleptically on certain mass death in Gaza. dissentmagazine.org/online_article…
Matthew Noah Smith He also says that they were “helping” Trump win by criticizing Harris’ position, but then not consider whether there was anything Harris could’ve done/said to try to win them over
Matthew Noah Smith One can argue that (1) Harris couldn’t have taken another position or else she’ll lose, and (2) since she’ll be better than Trump on the issue, 3) people who care about the issue should not criticize her, if only instrumentally. But (1) needs to be examined and not just assumed