profile-img
Gautam Bhatia

@gautambhatia88

Constitutional law. Science fiction. Co-ordinating editor @strangehorizons. Author of The Wall and The Horizon: https://t.co/uCAdGYOqg5.

calendar_today06-11-2010 06:28:00

79,3K Tweets

130,9K Followers

2,7K Following

Gautam Bhatia(@gautambhatia88) 's Twitter Profile Photo

(Re-)reading for class today, what in my view is one of the best civil liberties decisions from any court in recent years: the judgment of the Hong Kong First Instance Court striking down a ban on face masks, which was targeted at protesters --

legalref.judiciary.hk/lrs/common/ju/…

account_circle
Gautam Bhatia(@gautambhatia88) 's Twitter Profile Photo

One little bit of oral history is that this judgment came out right in the middle of the 2019 Kashmir internet shut-down, and we brought it to the notice of the SC, which was hearing the challenge. The States' arguments in both cases were strikingly similar.

account_circle
Gautam Bhatia(@gautambhatia88) 's Twitter Profile Photo

The SC's own judgment came out a few months later (Anuradha Bhasin vs Union of India), and the two make for interesting comparison:

indiankanoon.org/doc/82461587/

account_circle