Mohamad Omar Nachawati Abu Mus'ab Al-Kurdi Lastly, I'd appreciate you presenting your evidence on how the unarmed harbi male of fighting age belongs to the category of the exception which you so love to appeal to.

This is how you establish your case against AAA.

Marching Forward 🕋 ✍️ Abu Mus'ab Al-Kurdi Again, as I elaborated before, I find it wildly unreasonable for you to use the mixture of ayat and ahadith mentioned by Fernando to try to justify the intentional targeted killing of civilian men. Do you really defend the actions of AQAP and Abdulmutallab? Wicked.

Mohamad Omar Nachawati Abu Mus'ab Al-Kurdi They are valid evidences as they discuss the general ruling of fighting the polytheists, and then the exceptions.
Your job is to prove to us the adult harbi male is an exception. No one cares what you deem reasonable or not, as you agreed earlier this deen is by evidence.

Marching Forward 🕋 ✍️ Abu Mus'ab Al-Kurdi 'They are valid evidences as they discuss the general ruling of fighting the polytheists' -- are you trying to convince me that ahadith about the collective punishment of Banu Qurayza for their treachery is a 'general ruling of fighting the polytheists' that serves as evidence

Mohamad Omar Nachawati Abu Mus'ab Al-Kurdi Awaiting your evidence to the contrary 😴

Marching Forward 🕋 ✍️ Abu Mus'ab Al-Kurdi I've already explained to you why I don't find the mixture of verses and ahadith mentioned in Fernando's post to be evidence to justify the intentional targeted killing of civilian men, especially in a manner carried out by AAA associate Abdulmutallab.
twitter.com/realNachawati/…

Mohamad Omar Nachawati Abu Mus'ab Al-Kurdi No one cares about your explanation if you are not prepared to cite a single evidence supporting your stance.

Marching Forward 🕋 ✍️ Abu Mus'ab Al-Kurdi If that's the case, then why even provide me with Fernando's post in the first place?

Mohamad Omar Nachawati Abu Mus'ab Al-Kurdi Because it contained hadith on the prophet's approach in dealing with the male captives, which you could barely address

Marching Forward 🕋 ✍️ Abu Mus'ab Al-Kurdi The particular captives that you are speaking of are Banu Qurayza, and again, as I explained before, I find it wildly unreasonable to use the collective punishment of Banu Qurayza for their treachery as general evidence to justify the killing of non-Muslim civilian men, who by

Marching Forward 🕋 ✍️ Abu Mus'ab Al-Kurdi But I do wonder if Ahmad Jibril, Abdulaziz Alhaqqan and Assim Alhakeem agree with your claim that it is generally permissible to kill non-Muslim civilian men.